Wow…This was THE BEST IDOL show ever. I had my doubts at first but everyone really stepped up there game tonight. All the performances were relevant and current. Everyone really wants to win this! The iTunes could have been a mess of a theme but instead I kind of find myself wanting iTunes night every week for the rest of the competition. IS that wrong? I can NOT wait to start talking about the show so let’s get right to it.
Um…April Fools. And I ain’t just talking about the fool who came up with this night. *shakes head* This was the worst Idol show of the season.
There is a lot of terrifying hair on stage tonight. Interested to see how this relates to the theme which has something to do with iTunes, but has been kept tightly under wraps for some reason. (Ah, I was so naive and innocent when I wrote this originally…who knew the hellish nightmare that was about to unfold.)
While the judges discuss how this Top 9 is shaping I will…hold on, Kara has been asked to define artistry which has become quite the joke on the Interwebs. Paula is of course asked if she has any props under her skirt, but we are given the all clear. Finally, Simon says he is looking forward to Ryan being amazing.
Allison’s dress has frightened Harry Hamlin and Lisa Renna’s small children.
The American Tool (Ryan Seacrest) invites the Top 9 to his radio show. The theme this week is most popular downloads. The children giggle in wonder as Ryan uses a computer and makes sounds by using a mouse.
This is American Idol…
1-Anoop Dawg
“Caught Up” by Usher

The back-up singers are front and center for the beginning of the number which ends up being the most exciting part of the performance. Unfortunately, Anoop hasn’t even a quarter of the charisma that Usher has. This performance was as exciting as a dental hygiene commercial.
Kandy basically calls him out on the dare that his college frat boys made to him.
Mother Paula is wearing a lot of pop rocks on her neck but thanks him for having fun again.
Simon calls it a complete an utter mess and told him that it gave him a headache.
Anoop isn’t wearing a tie tonight, but he is wearing an arrogance ascot tonight as he does not take kindly to the harsh comments from ALL the judges. Hysterical in all of this is the several shots of his group of college frat boys sitting in the audience.
You get 1 old woman showing you her dentures because that is how fresh and cool your performance was.

2-Megan Joy Corkrey
“Turn Your Lights Down Now”

Bob Marley?
Lauryn Hill?
Really.
Lady CawCaw proves that in fact, anyone can sing Reggae badly.
I also wonder how she can get any sense of rhythm based on her dancing.
Kandy is interrupted by the audience who are calling here a “broken” record.
Paula asks her to dig deep to find where the beauty grows and offers her advice to do a ballad on a stool with no accompaniment (i.e. what Banshee Queen did last week).
Simon and Kandy offer no help at all by telling her for the 700th time to be like Adele, Duffy, or Amy Winehouse.
You get 1 exploding light bulb because those lights don’t need to be dimmed, they need to be destroyed!

3-Ghoulish Widower
“What Hurts The Most” by Rascal Flatts

GOkey brings out the strings to “soften” the song and “sing his heart out”. Well, he doesn’t know how to do subtle as this was the guy who had a picture of his dead wife shown while someone pointed up to Heaven during the Hollywood rounds. His vocals were overpowering and he pushed way to hard. However, it was leaps and bounds better than the two previous performances so the judges will of course eat it up.
Paula keeps it real and doesn’t lose her mind.
Simon claps, calls him a race horse, and drops the old “that was your best performance”.
Kandy has introduced “swagger” into his vocabulary. The show started now…you moved everyone in the room tonight…and gave me goosebumps in that special place.
You get two copies of the Goosebumps book “Night Of The Living Dummy” because I feel like the title pretty much describes your performance style.


4-Allison Iraheta
“Don’t Speak” by No Doubt

Playing the guitar.
Okay. The song didn’t need to be as bad as her dress and hair. She should have just played the guitar and kept it low and vulnerable.
Kandy talked about the clothes. Not the performance. Just clothes.
Paula accurately describes the guitar and used the word intonation. Of course, she did not talk about the performance at all, so methinks she used the dictionary and wrote her critique in advance. However, she does say for the first time that Allison will go to the end. THANK YOU for acknowledging that someone else may be at the end besides Gokey, Adam, and Lil.
Simon agrees with Kandy and talks about the clothes. Seriously Simon…what is up?
You get three groups of frightened children and a few drunk Santas.



5-Mr. Magoo
“Just The Way You Are” by Billy Joel

The hair stylists clearly had fun at the expense of his blindness by styling his hair like Teen Wolf. The performance itself is astoundingly average. Scott can play the piano. Scott can sing. He does both well, but he is never more than aiight.
Kandy jokingly tells him that she likes the new look. (The camera then shoots to his hot seeing eye brother)
Paula tells him that she watches him and forgets he is blind. (I’m think that is a compliment?)
Simon tells him that it is his best performance by a country mile. (I don’t disagree because I can’t think of a “better” performance he has given.)
You get two Teen Wolves…because seriously, how could I not.


6-Matt G.
“You Found Me” by The Fray (I AM SO TIRED OF THE SONG!!!)

Ryan cuts into the start of the song.
Matt G plays the keyboard in a members only jacket. Surprisingly 80s for a modern song. Here’s the deal:
Matt wants to be British.
The judges want him to be Soul.
Never the twain shall meet.
Paula reminds him of the “Coldplay” performance and tells him it was too sound-alike.
Simon tells him that he is trying to be to many people.
Kandy tells him to let the flavor out and that he doesn’t deserve to go home.
You get three casts of Lost because oddly enough Simon, this song was so commercial…it was used in an actual commercial.



7-Lil Rounds
“I Surrender” by Celine Dion

OH MY GOD!
In no universe, should Lil ever sing a song by “Celine Dion”.
That being said, it wasn’t nearly as terrible as I expected it to be. There are times when she would go for those notes, she would look a bit like a fish. I was pretty much hypnotized by that.
Kandy said that she should sing Mary J. or Keyisha Cole (I agree) Mariah or Eric Carmen (I don’t agree and who ever suggests “Eric Carmen”).
Paula said that she doesn’t want to see Adult Contemporary Lil Rounds ever again. Never ever!
Simon told Lil that she is slowly dying. (Not unlike this night)
Ryan brings her children to hug Randy as the producers try desperately to keep Lil in the competition.
You get three Celine Dions because I want you to look closely at these pictures and ask yourself, is this really who you want to become?



8-The Banshee Queen
“Play That Funky Music” by Wild Cherry

lol! This is going to be AWESOME!!! (What I thought before the performance started)
Sadly, he even disappointed me tonight. He turned Contemporary Night into Disco Night, but what else would you expect from a Queen.
Paula places him on the same level as Mick Jagger and Steven Tyler. (But his lips aren’t big enough)
Simon calls him brave and says that it doesn’t matter. (Which is kind of true)
Kandy calls it Studio 57. (Six words for you Kandy: I think you mean Studio 54)
You get 4 Glitter Lips. No explanation needed.




9-Kris Allen
“Ain’t No Sunshine”
AWESOME!!!
THE BEST PERFORMANCE OF THE NIGHT!! (At this point I am so desperate to cling to anything remotely redeemable that I am practically crying because this performance didn’t make me die inside. However, he could of course done it better by just sticking to the keyboard and not messing with the band, but at least he turned it back down for the end of the song)
Kandy: Three words…THAT IS ARTISTRY!
Paula: First cut from the album.
Simon: You brought the swagger.
You get 5 rudimentary drawings of the sun because that is what you’re performance inspired.





Final Thoughts:
Who knew that any theme could be more painful than Country Night!?
There are so many Idols who are in trouble, let us name those who are safe.
Kris Allen, the boy you’d bring home to mother
and
Adam Lambert, the boy who would wear your mother’s clothes.
Everyone else is not safe. There is a chance Lil is okay because she picked a safe song and finished notes for the first time on the Idol Stage (thanks for reading the blog, Lil:-) Also, Ryan forcing her little boy to punch Randy may have bought her some votes. I suppose that Gokey made a deal with the devil will be staying, but everyone else is in trouble. Matt G. was slightly better which may save him from the bottom three.
Megan Joy, Scott, and Anoop will likely create your bottom three this week and I don’t really think the judges will save any of them. On a different note, I am glad to FINALLY see the judges stop pimping Gokey, Adam, and Lil
and finally admit that Kris and Allison have a chance to make it to the Final Three!
Here’s hoping Idol learns from their mistakes and NEVER EVER subjects ANY ONE to iTunes night again!
I’m serious Idol! Don’t even think about it!
J Ramp Out!